Nucleophilic Aromatic Substitution Vs Electrophilic Aromatic Substitution Latest 2023

A nucleophilic aromatic substitution is a substitution reaction in organic chemistry in which the nucleophile displaces a good leaving group, such as a halide, on an aromatic ring. Aromatic rings are usually nucleophilic, but some aromatic compounds do undergo nucleophilic substitution. Just as normally nucleophilic alkenes can be made to undergo conjugate substitution if they carry electron-withdrawing substituents, so normally nucleophilic aromatic rings also become electrophilic if they have the right substituents.

This reaction differs from a common S_N2 reaction, because it happens at a trigonal carbon atom (sp² hybridization). The mechanism of S_N2 reaction does not occur due to steric hindrance of the benzene ring. In order to attack the C atom, the nucleophile must approach in line with the C-LG (leaving group) bond from the back, where the benzene ring lies. It follows the general rule for which S_N2 reactions occur only at a tetrahedral carbon atom.

The S_N1 mechanism is possible but very unfavourable unless the leaving group is an exceptionally good one. It would involve the unaided loss of the leaving group and the formation of an aryl cation. In the S_N1 reactions all the cations employed as intermediates were planar with an empty p orbital. This cation is planar but the p orbital is full (it is part of the aromatic ring) and the empty orbital is an sp² orbital outside the ring.

The are six different mechanism by which aromatic rings undergo nucleophilic substitution.

Nucleophilic aromatic substitution mechanisms

There are 6 nucleophilic substitution mechanisms encountered with aromatic systems:

1. The S_NAr (addition-elimination) mechanism
   
2. The aromatic S_N1 mechanism encountered with diazonium salts
   
3. The benzyne mechanism (E1cb-Ad_N)
   
4. The free radical S_RN1 mechanism
5. ANRORC mechanism
6. Vicarious nucleophilic substitution.

The S_NAr mechanism is the most important of these. Electron withdrawing groups activate the ring towards nucleophilic attack. For example if there are nitro functional groups positioned ortho or para to the halide leaving group, the S_NAr mechanism is favored.

S_NAr reaction mechanism

The following is the reaction mechanism of a nucleophilic aromatic substitution of 2,4-dinitrochlorobenzene in a basic solution in water.

In this sequence the carbon atoms are numbered clockwise from 1–6 starting with the 1 carbon at 12 o’clock, which is bonded to the chlorine atom. Since the nitro group is an activator toward nucleophilic substitution, and a meta director, it allows the benzene carbon atom to which it is bonded to have a negative charge. In the Meisenheimer complex, the nonbonded electrons of the carbanion become bonded to the aromatic pi system which allows the ipso carbon atom to temporarily bond with the hydroxyl group (-OH). In order to return to a lower energy state, either the hydroxyl group leaves, or the chloride leaves. In solution both processes happen. A small percentage of the intermediate loses the chloride to become the product (2,4-dinitrophenol), while the rest return to the reactant. Since 2,4-dinitrophenol is in a lower energy state it will not return to form the reactant, so after some time has passed, the reaction reaches chemical equilibrium that favors the 2,4-dinitrophenol.

The formation of the resonance-stabilized Meisenheimer complex is slow because it is in a higher energy state than the aromatic reactant. The loss of the chloride is fast, because the ring becomes aromatic again. Recent work indicates that, sometimes, the Meisenheimer complex is not always a true intermediate but may be the transition state of a ‘frontside S_N2′ process, particularly if stabilization by electron-withdrawing groups is not very strong. A 2019 review argues that such ‘concerted S_NAr’ reactions are more prevalent than previously assumed.

Aryl halides cannot undergo the classic ‘backside’ S_N2 reaction. The carbon-halogen bond is in the plane of the ring because the carbon atom has a trigonal planar geometry. Backside attack is blocked and this reaction is therefore not possible. An S_N1 reaction is possible but very unfavourable. It would involve the unaided loss of the leaving group and the formation of an aryl cation. The nitro group is the most commonly encountered activating group, other groups are the cyano and the acyl group. The leaving group can be a halogen or a sulfide. With increasing electronegativity the reaction rate for nucleophilic attack increases. This is because the rate-determining step for an S_NAr reaction is attack of the nucleophile and the subsequent breaking of the aromatic system; the faster process is the favourable reforming of the aromatic system after loss of the leaving group. As such, the following pattern is seen with regard to halogen leaving group ability for S_NAr: F > Cl ≈ Br > I (i.e. an inverted order to that expected for an S_N2 reaction). If looked at from the point of view of an S_N2 reaction this would seem counterintuitive, since the C-F bond is amongst the strongest in organic chemistry, when indeed the fluoride is the ideal leaving group for an S_NAr due to the extreme polarity of the C-F bond. Nucleophiles can be amines, alkoxides, sulfides and stabilized carbanions.

Nucleophilic aromatic substitution reactions

Some typical substitution reactions on arenes are listed below.

• In the Bamberger rearrangement N-phenylhydroxylamines rearrange to 4-aminophenols. The nucleophile is water.
• In the Sandmeyer reaction diazonium salts react with halides.
• The Smiles rearrangement is the intramolecular version of this reaction type.

Nucleophilic aromatic substitution is not limited to arenes, however; the reaction takes place even more readily with heteroarenes. Pyridines are especially reactive when substituted in the aromatic ortho position or aromatic para position because then the negative charge is effectively delocalized at the nitrogen position. One classic reaction is the Chichibabin reaction (Aleksei Chichibabin, 1914) in which pyridine is reacted with an alkali-metal amide such as sodium amide to form 2-aminopyridine.

In the compound methyl 3-nitropyridine-4-carboxylate, the meta nitro group is actually displaced by fluorine with cesium fluoride in DMSO at 120 °C.

Asymmetric nucleophilic aromatic substitution

With carbon nucleophiles such as 1,3-dicarbonyl compounds the reaction has been demonstrated as a method for the asymmetric synthesis of chiral molecules. First reported in 2005, the organocatalyst (in a dual role with that of a phase transfer catalyst) is derived from cinchonidine (benzylated at N and O).

See also

• Electrophilic aromatic substitution
• Nucleophile
• Substitution reaction
• SN1 reaction
• SN2 reaction
• SNi reaction
• Nucleophilic aliphatic substitution
• Nucleophilic acyl substitution

References

Nucleophilic substitutions Electrophilic substitutions Elimination reactions Addition reactions Unimolecular reactions Electron/Proton transfer reactions Medium effects Related topics Chemical kinetics